Murder Mystery Shop
Shop our one-time standalone mysteries. Shipping is on us.
|
Save more than 15% when ordering one of these 4-pack mystery bundles.
|
Add a little something to your mystery order.
|
Save big on gifting a one-time annual subscription. Does not renew. It's a one-time purchase.
|
Cosplay Casualty
FREE SHIPPING
Cosplay Casualty - Murder Mystery Box
Old Crow's Village is hosting its annual movie and comic convention. Investigator August Fuller has recruited you to join him in investigating an unfortunate death at the convention. It's up to you to get to the root of things and find the prime suspect by reviewing the evidence collected and interviewing the suspects.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days after ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Cruel Summer
FREE SHIPPING
Cruel Summer - Murder Mystery Box
Castaway Camp is reopening for the first time in nearly a decade. As the counselors settle in to prep the camp for the incoming campers, things start to fall apart when a murder is committed. What's more is the counselors are seemingly cut off from the rest of the world. Can they get to the bottom of things with a killer among them? Or will they become victims themselves? Examine the evidence & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days after ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Sugar Frosted Murder
FREE SHIPPING
Sugar Frosted Murder - Murder Mystery Box
Tragedy strikes during a launch party for a new flavor of cupcake at a small-town baking company. Your help is needed to aid in the investigation. With the higher-ups breathing down your neck and the father of the victim wanting answers, can you catch the prime suspect? Examine the evidence & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days after ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
The Nevermore
Sold out
FREE SHIPPING
The Nevermore Murder Mystery Box
On the wintery road to a retreat, a group of aspiring poets find themselves stranded at a crumbling motel inspired by Edgar Allan Poe. After an unexpected death and no way to call for help, it's up to the remaining guests to figure out what is happening at The Nevermore. Examine the evidence & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days after ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Port Paradise
FREE SHIPPING
Port Paradise Murder Mystery Box
Join WInston Remington on Stab Island in his overwater villa at the Port Paradise Resort. While on the isle to scout a job offer, things start to go sidewise. The resort lives up to it's name until guest is found dead. Can you help determine who is responsible? Examine the evidence & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Grave Danger
FREE SHIPPING
Grave Danger Murder Mystery Box
Remains are found in a shallow grave. This appears to be the work of a serial killer as the apparent killer is taunting the authorities. Follow the journal and the evidence that Gregor, a veteran detective on shaky ground, collected. Can you help determine who is responsible? Examine the evidence & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
That's So 90's
FREE SHIPPING
That's So 90's Murder Mystery Box
A 90's themed fundraiser is a blast from the past for former high school friends. The attendees get more than they bargained for when a murder is committed. With a familiar detective on the case, friends of the victim wonder if justice will be served for their fallen friend or if the mystery shall go unsolved. Examine the evidence collected & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Boots, Chaps, & Cowboy Hats
FREE SHIPPING
Boots, Chaps & Cowboy Hats Murder Mystery Box
A group of friends go on an overnight getaway at a ranch to have a western-themed Murder Mystery Dinner Party. When one of them is found dead, they suspect each other of murder. Can you detect who's guilty? Follow the journal on the events of the evening as told by Lars. Examine the evidence collected & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Fear the Reaper
FREE SHIPPING
Fear the Reaper Murder Mystery Box
A Halloween party at a supposedly haunted house known locally as The House of the Reaper guarantees to be a night of spooky surprises. Unfortunately, not all of the costumed party-goers will survive their stay in The House of the Reaper. Follow the journal Eddie Sandusky kept on the events of the evening, examine the evidence collected, & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Death Dealer
FREE SHIPPING
Death Dealer Murder Mystery Box
Join Hayden Lockhart in a reluctant investigation into a missing family friend. Evidence unfolds revealing far more to this situation than expected. With a dealer of death taking aim and multiple victims surfacing, can you determine whodunit before time runs out? Follow the journal of her notes on the case, examine the evidence collected, & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
The Guilty Party
FREE SHIPPING
The Guilty Party Murder Mystery Box
Things don't go as planned for a small Savannah wedding. When a member of the wedding party parishes, the quest to find the truth begins. Could it have been a tragic accident or is a member of the wedding party the guilty party? Join Mia Hudson's investigation. Follow the journal of her notes on the case, examine the evidence collected, & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Blizzard Betrayal
FREE SHIPPING
Blizzard Betrayal Murder Mystery Box
Tempers rise as temperatures drop.
The Scanlon family gathers at a cabin on a remote island in Alaska to say goodbye to a loved one. What should have been a weekend of remembrance, quickly turns to tragedy. The family turns on each other in an effort to get to the truth. Will they unmask the murderer before time runs out?
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Scarlet Oak Slaying
FREE SHIPPING
Scarlet Oak Slaying Murder Mystery Box
An overnight ghost hunting investigation goes awry when a reporter joins the team. They are all in for a night of surprises and when a murder is committed, things spiral out of control.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
What Happened in Vegas
FREE SHIPPING
What Happened in Vegas Murder Mystery Box
Tyson Merrick is called back to his hometown of Las Vegas for a job prospect. Shortly after his arrival, Tyson finds himself entangled in multiple homicide cases. Even more startling, Tyson has connections to the victims. As the eyes of suspicion fall his way, he attempts to solve the case.
Join Tyson's investigation. Follow the journal he kept, examine the evidence collected, & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
What Goes Around
FREE SHIPPING
What Goes Around Murder Mystery Box
A group of acquaintances reunite after a terrible accident occurs that may be linked to a tragedy from their past. What links this group together? Have the sins of the past caught up with them or is it all just coincidence?
Join William Van Dorn's investigation. Follow the journal he kept, examine the evidence collected, & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Hollywood Horror
FREE SHIPPING
Hollywood Horror Murder Mystery Box
When things go awry at a fan fest event, a movie star's life is threatened. A superfan finds himself in the mix amidst the drama that unfolds. Soon, a murder is committed and a series of anonymous letters are found. Join Kit Ashby, as she follows the evidence to find the killer and solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Dead on Arrival
FREE SHIPPING
Dead on Arrival Murder Mystery Box
Not one, but two residents of an apartment building are found dead in the community courtyard. Could it have been an accident? Could they have died of natural causes? Or, could it be murder? Neighbors become suspects as motives are uncovered. Join Detective Sullivan Streeter as he investigates the case by keeping a journal and gathering evidence to solve this mystery. Follow the journal of his notes on the case, examine the evidence collected, & solve the case.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
A Matter of Murder
FREE SHIPPING
Murder Mystery Box: A Matter of Murder
Detective Mosby has settled down in the sleepy town of Stone Grove, a place with very little crime. When Mosby catches a murder case, he's just as stunned as everyone else. While conducting his investigation, something equally unsettling strikes Stone Grove. Join Mosby on his quest to solve a matter of murder.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
A Score to Settle
FREE SHIPPING
A Score to Settle Murder Mystery Box
A college reunion at a zipline park turns out to be far more dangerous than anyone expected. Secrets of the past have a way revealing themselves.
Will there be any survivors of this nightmarish adventure park or will it become their final resting place?
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
The Sequoia Hotel
FREE SHIPPING
The Sequoia Hotel Murder Mystery Box
A soft opening of a hotel, nestled in a northern California forest, looks to be a night of extravagance. A small group of reviewers are invited to stay in the hotel ahead of the grand opening. When tragedy strikes, will the group come together to find out what happened or will they turn on each other?
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Treasures Lost
FREE SHIPPING
Treasures Lost Murder Mystery Box
A family adventure to seek a lost treasure turns deadly. A series of unfortunate mishaps plague the Shull family's quest. When things take a tragic turn, will the family discover what really happened?
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Misfortune in Missouri
FREE SHIPPING
Misfortune in Missouri Murder Mystery Box
A road trip takes a wrong turn. Amidst hellish weather and closed roadways, a young man finds himself stranded when a murder takes place. Can he determine who the killer is before the murderer escapes? Or will he fall victim for his part in investigating the crime?
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Homicide Under the Big Top
FREE SHIPPING
Homicide Under the Big Top Murder Mystery Box
The main attraction in a traveling carnival has perished. The police suspect murder. Was the death simply an accident or something more sinister? Can the case be solved before the carnival moves on to the next town?
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Terror in the Tropics
FREE SHIPPING
Terror in the Tropics Murder Mystery Box
Trapped on an uninhabited island, a group of survivors must fight for their lives as a murderer is among them. Will the murderer be uncovered? Or, will they all fall victim to a fate of death?
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Treadwell Ranch
FREE SHIPPING
Treadwell Ranch Murder Mystery Box
A group's weekend stay at Treadwell Ranch turns out to be more than they bargained for when a murder is committed. Can you find the murderer and the motive for the crime?
Treadwell Ranch Murder Mystery Box
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Crimson Springs
Save 10% Ships Free
Crimson Springs Murder Mystery Box
The disappearance of a young woman leads a rookie private investigator to a small, lake town. Join Lefty in solving a murder mystery in Crimson Springs.
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Masquerade Murder
FREE SHIPPING
Murder Mystery Box: Masquerade Murder
When Jack Pell is invited to a masquerade party in New Orleans that ends in murder, he decides to do a little investigating. Using the journal he kept and the clues he picked up along the way, can you solve the case?
One-Time orders go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
One-Time Bundles, Annual Gift Subscriptions, & Foul Play Mystery Game
Spooky Season Bundle
Sold out
FREE SHIPPING
Spooky Season Bundle
Channel your inner investigator with our murder mysteries. Examine the evidence such as photos, suspect interviews, and other collected clues to help you solve the case.
Bundle up in that cozy chair with a cuppa and save more than 15% with our Spooky Season Bundle. Includes (4) One-Time, Standalone mysteries:
- The Nevermore
- Fear the Reaper
- Death Dealer
- What Goes Around
Shipping is on us.
No internet, QR codes, barcodes, or calls are required to crack the case. All you need is the box and its contents to solve the mystery. You can go off-grid and bring your Murder Mystery Boxes along with you.
FREE SHIPPING: Bundles go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Summer Vibes Bundle
FREE SHIPPING
Summer Vibes Bundle
Channel your inner investigator with our murder mysteries. Examine the evidence such as photos, suspect interviews, and other collected clues to help you solve the case.
Bundle up in that beach towel and save more than 15% with our Summer Vibes Bundle. Includes (4) One-Time, Standalone mysteries:
- Port Paradise
- Terror in the Tropics
- Crimson Springs
- A Score to Settle
Shipping is on us.
No internet, QR codes, barcodes, or calls are required to crack the case. All you need is the box and its contents to solve the mystery. You can go off-grid and bring your Murder Mystery Boxes along with you.
FREE SHIPPING: Bundles go to post approximately two business days of ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
Law & Order Bundle
Law & Order Bundle
Channel your inner investigator with our murder mysteries. Examine the evidence such as photos, suspect interviews, and other collected clues to help you solve the case.
Bundle up in that beach towel and save more than 15% with our Law & Order Bundle. Includes (4) One-Time, Standalone mysteries:
- What Happened in Vegas
- Dead on Arrival
- Grave Danger
- A Matter of Murder
No internet, QR codes, barcodes, or calls are required to crack the case. All you need is the box and its contents to solve the mystery. You can go off-grid and bring your Murder Mystery Boxes along with you.
FREE SHIPPING: Bundles go to post approximately two business days after ordering. At this time, we only ship within the United States.
One-Time Annual Subscription
Need a last minute gift idea?
Order an annual subscription for that detective in your life. The first mystery in their year of mystery shall ship in mid-month following the end of the quarter.
A one year subscription (4 quarterly boxes) FREE SHIPPING
Save more than 15% off the price of ordering four one-time mysteries & 13% off of the quarterly subscription price.
Annual Subscriptions do NOT renew. It's a one-time purchase.
Read the journal, open the evidence, review the clues, and solve the case. Everything to solve the mystery is in the box- no internet needed. All mysteries sent to our subscribers are new mysteries that have not yet been released to our one-time box section.
The first box shall ship following the end of the current calendar quarter.
Boxes ship mid-month in January, April, July, & October. See shipping schedule image for more details.
It will not auto renew at the end of the cycle, and is non-refundable.
If your order is a gift, scroll to the bottom of the page to print out a PDF letter & shipment schedule for your recipient to hold them over until the next quarter box ships.
Mystery Game: Foul Play
Save 40%
- Foul Play Murder Mystery Game contains three cases:
- A Case of Murder
- A Killer Among Us
- A Motive for Murder
- Play a scavenger hunt-type murder mystery game with 2 or more players
- Read the case introduction
- Review the suspects
- Investigate the clue cards
- Deduce your conclusion
Orders go to post within 2 business days
Add Ons
Crime Scene Wristlet Keychain
Show off your sleuthing skills with a Crime Scene Wristlet Lanyard. Made from cotton webbing and grosgrain ribbon, this lanyard wristlet is approximately 6" in length when flat and 1" wide. Attach those keys and get on your way to solving mysteries.
Includes:
-> (1) Crime Scene Tape Styled Wristlet
Add to your Murder Mystery Box order and skip the shipping.
Killer Coffee Keychain Set
Fueled by Killer Coffee Keychain Set
Attach your keychain to your keys, bag, or backpack, or split it up among your various keyrings.
--(1) Key Set including:
- Wooden Fueled by Killer Coffee Key Tag
- Fluffy Coffee Colored Pom Pom
- Capsule to hold a few aspirin or medication
- Killer Kitty Charm with Coffee Beans
- Skeleton Key Shaped Bottle Opener
- Hand Sanitizer Bottle (empty) & Holder -just fill with your favorite sanitizer
- Emergency Whistle
- Satin Luster Glass Pearl Beads
Add to your Murder Mystery Box order and skip the shipping.
Fueled by Wine & True Crime Keychain Set
Fueled by Wine & True Crime Keychain Set
Attach your keychain to your keys, bag, or backpack, or split it up among your various keyrings.
--(1) Key Set including:
- Wooden Fueled by Wine & True Crime Key Tag
- Small Red Wine Colored Pom Pom With Wine Glasses Charms
- Capsule to hold a few aspirin or medication
- Skeleton Key Shaped Bottle Opener
- Hand Sanitizer Bottle (empty) & Holder with Keyring -just fill with your favorite sanitizer
- Emergency Whistle
- Satin Luster Glass Pearl Beads with Killin it Knife Charm
Add to your Murder Mystery Box order and skip the shipping.
Alibi Wodden Key Tag
Just Here to Establish an Alibi Wooden Key Tag
Attach your to your keys, bag, or backpack, and show everyone why you're really here.
Includes: (1) Wooden key fob with keychain ring
Add to your Murder Mystery Box order and skip the shipping.
Establish an Alibi Keychain
I'm Just Here to Establish an Alibi Keychain
Attach your keychain to your keys, bag, or backpack, and show everyone why you're really here.
Includes: (1) Brown PU leather key fob with keychain ring and rivet
Add to your Murder Mystery Box order and skip the shipping.
Mystery Solver Keychain
Mystery Solver Keychain
Attach your keychain to your keys, bag, or backpack, and show everyone that you are a mystery solver.
Includes: (1) Red PU leather key fob with keychain ring and rivet
Add to your Murder Mystery Box order and skip the shipping.
Crime Scene Lanyard & Two Wrist Bands
Includes:
-> (1) Crime Scene Tape Styled Lanyard
-> (2) Rubber Crime Scene Tape Styled Wrist Bands
Add to your Murder Mystery Box order and skip the shipping.
Mystery Shows & Comfy Clothes Keychain
Mystery Shows & Comfy Clothes Keychain
Attach your keychain to your keys, bag, or backpack, and show off your love of mystery shows and comfy clothes.
Includes: (1) Light Brown PU leather key fob with keychain ring and rivet
Add to your Murder Mystery Box order and skip the shipping.
Killer Kitty Keychain
Attach your Killer Kitty keychain to your keys, bag, or backpack, and show the Killer Kitty is on the prowl.
Includes: (1) Killer Kitty Keychain
Add to your Murder Mystery Box order and skip the shipping.
Armchair Detective Zip Around Bag
Armchair Detective Zip Around Bag
Keep your ear phones, charging cords, and other miscellaneous stuffs in your red Armchair Detective case. The words are laser etched on the surface of the case.
Includes: (1) Zip Around Armchair Detective Case
Add to your Murder Mystery Box order and skip the shipping.
